They Were Never a Customer. Can You Get the Google Review Removed?

2026-09-24

You have checked the bookings, the invoices and the till records. Nobody by that name has ever bought from you, and the one-star review describes something you do not recognise. It feels like the simplest removal case there could be.

It usually is not, and the reason catches out almost every owner we speak to. Whether the review comes down depends on what the reviewer wrote, not on what your records show.

The admission has to be in their words

Reviews are meant to describe a real experience with the business. Google's Fake Engagement policy covers content that does not, and a review from someone who never dealt with you falls squarely under it.

The catch is where the proof comes from. The case exists when the reviewer says in their own words, on the page, that they never used your business. People do this more often than you would think, usually because they are reviewing something they heard about rather than something they experienced.

Wording that qualifies (invented examples):

• "Haven't been in and never will after hearing how they treat people."
• "Not a customer, just passing on what my neighbour told me."

In both, the reviewer has done the work for you. They have admitted there was no visit, no purchase and no service, so the review cannot describe an experience at your business.

Wording that only looks similar:

• "Worst service I've had in years." You have no record of them, but the review claims an experience.
• "Rang for a quote and never heard back." That is an experience.

Why your records will not carry it

It is tempting to build the report on your own records: no booking, no invoice, no customer by that name. Google does not check your records, and there are plenty of ordinary reasons a real customer will not match them:

• They reviewed under a nickname, a first name only, or an old account.
• They used a partner's or family member's Google account.
• The booking was in someone else's name, or it was a company account.
• They paid cash and never gave a name at all.

Google knows all of this. A report built on "we have no customer by that name" asks Google to take your word over theirs, and that is not a contest Google will referee. Keep your records out of the report and out of the appeal. They belong in your public reply, where they do a better job anyway.

There is a second cost to leaning on them. An appeal that says "this person was never our customer" turns a question about the words on the page into a dispute about what happened, and Google does not settle disputes. You would be spending your one appeal on that review on an argument it will not hear.

If you are trying to work out who is behind a review, our post on who left an anonymous Google review explains what you can and cannot find out.

Quotes, enquiries and phone calls count

A reviewer who got a quote, made an enquiry, sent an email or had a phone call with you has had an experience with your business. "Asked about prices and got attitude" is a review of that phone call, and it stays.

This surprises owners who feel that someone who never paid should not get a vote. They do. So when a review describes an enquiry, stop looking for a never-a-customer case and read it again for one of the other breaches Google acts on. Angry reviews often contain one: a label like "scammers", swearing aimed at a person, or an attack on a named employee. Our posts on reviews calling your business a scam and reviews attacking a staff member cover the two most common.

Two related cases are worth separating out. If you believe the reviewer is a former employee writing as if they were a customer, that is a conflict of interest, and it needs proof rather than an admission; see what to do about a fake review from an ex-employee. If you believe it is a rival, the same applies, and our guide to getting a competitor's review removed explains what evidence counts.

Reporting it and what goes in the appeal

Take a screenshot of the review first, so you keep the admission if the reviewer edits it later. Then report it from Google's Reviews Management Tool, signed in to the account that owns or manages your profile, and pick Spam. There is no text box at the report stage, so the reason does all the work. From the public listing or the Maps app, where Spam is not offered, pick Low quality information.

If the report comes back "no policy violation", the review becomes eligible for appeal. In the policy field, type Fake Engagement. In the explanation, quote the admission word for word and show that, in the reviewer's own words, there was no experience with your business. Nothing about your records, your other reviews or how unfair it is. The admission is your strongest evidence, so the appeal is built on it alone.

The wording that ties the admission to the policy is where these appeals are won, and The Google Review Removal Playbook has the template for this breach with a worked example. If you have not lodged an appeal before, start with how to appeal a Google review decision.

When the review does not say it: the reply

Most reviews from people you cannot place will not contain an admission. That does not leave you empty-handed. Your reply can make the point for you, publicly, without an accusation you would have to prove.

A good reply here does four things:

• Thanks them and takes it seriously, so it does not read as defensive.
• Says plainly that you cannot match it to a visit, job or order, while allowing that you may be missing something.
• Invites them to get in touch with a date or the name the booking was under.
• Gives a direct contact, a name and an email or phone number.

Something like "We cannot find a visit that matches this, and I would like to understand what happened" carries it. Every reader sees an owner who checked, stayed polite and asked for details. If the reviewer never replies, readers draw their own conclusion, and you never had to write the word "fake".

What the reply must not do is accuse. "You were never here" or "this is a fake review" invites an argument you cannot win in public and looks worse to the next customer than the review itself. Our post on how to reply to a fake Google review goes further, and the playbook includes the full reply template for a reviewer you do not recognise.

Before you do anything else

Put your records to one side for a minute and read the review as a stranger would.

1. Does the reviewer say, in their own words, that they never used you? If yes, report it as Spam today and keep the screenshot.
2. Does it describe any contact at all, even a call or a quote? Then look for a different breach in the wording.
3. Nothing to point at? Reply the same day, using the approach above.

A bare warning with no visit described at all, like "Avoid, avoid, avoid", is still worth a free report, since it describes no experience of any kind.

Read the review twice: the admission is often buried in the last line, after the reviewer has spent a paragraph describing someone else's experience.

Several locations or a group? Talk to us about a managed service · Popular locations: Sydney · Melbourne · Brisbane · Perth · Adelaide · Gold Coast · all locations